The consequences of this switch-up can be extreme. In the United States there are two types of courts, there is juvenile court as well as an adult court, in some cases a juvenile because of the severity of his or her crime is brought into the adult courtroom in order to be tried as an adult. The juvenile law states that although most states try juveniles crime cases in juvenile court when the offenders is younger than 18, a few states have younger cutoffs Juvenile Law. So all in all, it is due to this 'yet to develop the thought processes of an adult' that demands us to treat them differently. This further hinders their ability to rehabilitate after they are released. We are now sending them straight back to that harsh schoolyard. Juveniles deserve to be tried the same as adults when they commit certain crimes.
The Right to a Trial By Jury The juvenile courts do not have a jury, and offenders are not given a proper trial. A state judge dismissed all criminal charges against her. Supreme Court has ruled capital punishment unconstitutional for anyone who hasn't celebrated their 16th birthday. Like those with mental handicaps, children? It has been suggested that the entire debate over whether or not to abolish the juvenile court diverts attention away from the most important question confronting the juvenile justice system: How can juvenile delinquency be reduced when neither the present juvenile courts nor adult criminal courts are designed to attack the various environmental factors that are among the causes of juvenile violence? Schools also play a part in generating juvenile violence. Despite this, however, they often actually serve only a fraction of the sentences imposed, in many cases less time than they would have served in a juvenile facility. Subjects were given intelligence tests and asked to respond to several hypothetical legal situations, such as whether to confess to a police officer. In some states, including Tennessee, there is now no minimum age for being transferred to criminal court for certain crimes.
Many believe that this is the wrong approach to take up as it does not focus on the main factor at hand - the crime that has been committed. That is if you are a rational being, free of psychological problems. Vanderbilt®, Vanderbilt University®, V Oak Leaf Design®, and Star V Design® are trademarks of The Vanderbilt University. If you can help today—because every gift of every size matters—please do. It makes complete sense that 16 is the set age for determining an offender an adult. Many may argue that by the age of ten children know what they are doing, enough to know the consequences…. These are the questions plaguing the American legal system today, as the violent acts of juvenile offenders continue to make headlines.
More and more teens now are doing time alongside adults in prison. The Pros of Juveniles Being Tried As Adults 1. Even an eleven year old being able to be tried as an adult for murder. However, all juveniles sentenced to incarceration received nearly identical sentence length, regardless of whether they were tried in the criminal or the juvenile system. In Texas, children stop being babies not when they hit puberty, drive, vote, enlist in the military or drink, but when they commit a violent crime. The trial phase of a juvenile case is an adjudication hearing. Why not call all these cry babies adults the minute they are able to wear big boy pants? By putting an end to juvenile crime before it even starts all of these problems with juveniles in the judicial system would be able to be avoided and society would be much safer and happier for everyone.
All but five states allow children of any age charged with murder to be tried as adults. It's unlikely that America's thirst for vengeance will be sated by scientific theory. Accountability is necessary from criminals. There are some people who feel… Should Juveniles be Tried as Adults? The district attorney argued that Cameron had lied when asked about the shooting -- and lying is something that adults do. Shawn was 16 in 1998 when… 1884 Words 8 Pages every day in the United States.
Yet some activists would put an end to that practice in every instance, no matter the crime and no matter the criminal. If they are convicted as juveniles, they would gain freedom from the system at age 25. The purpose of juvenile court is treatment and guidance rather than punishment. While that may be a gruesome punishment, being a young person should not excuse him of his action. Another reason for sending juveniles to a separate prison from adults is that the youth may be incompetent.
The judge has taken the motion under advisement. Many states are now opting for a cut in the age at which a person is considered a juvenile and not an adult criminal. No matter who commits it. List of Pros of Juveniles Being Tried as Adults 1. They found that juvenile arrests for the offenses targeted by the legislation actually increased in Idaho, while decreasing in the other two states.
Excluding the case of violent crimes, such as murder and rape, children should never be tried as adults… Should Juveniles be tried as Adults? The worker lived and was out of the hospital the same day of the shooting. Recent brain imaging technology reinforces the adolescent development literature. If the prosecutor has established probable cause, the judge must then decide on the minor's chances at rehabilitation as a juvenile. At what age should one be held accountable for their actions? It does not mean that because it was a child who committed the crime, the family of the victim does not continue to suffer. Light sentences don't teach kids the lesson they need to learn: If you commit a terrible crime, you will spend a considerable part of your life in jail. There's not been a lot of extensive research into the impact of laws making it easier to try kids as adults.
Should Juveniles Be Tried as Adults? Defense attorneys might offer a different argument: Since the bulk of the drop-off in juvenile crime predates most states' embrace of harsher penalties for young offenders, it is disingenuous to assume any connection between the two. Additionally, they argue that children and teenagers are capable of learning and changing thus, rehabilitation is the effective punishment. It's remarkably easy to find a seasoned defense lawyer who believes the current system is too vulnerable to racism: Statistically, black juvenile offenders are far more likely to be transferred to adult courts and serve adult time than their white peers who've committed comparable crimes. Violent crimes are committed in the United States every day. There are many battles to be won, but we will battle them together—all of us. We don't survive on clicks.