Irish potato famine genocide. Irish Potato famine: a genocide 2018-12-22

Irish potato famine genocide Rating: 7,3/10 561 reviews

Was the Irish Potato Famine really a genocide? : AskHistorians

irish potato famine genocide

You are no better than a Holocaust Denier. If not I suggest your embarrassment at your friends solidarity with the nationalist community there is miss-placed. The Irish used to bleed cattle and drink the blood mixed with milk for sustenance as well. What Was The Irish Potato Famine? Though many Holocaust Irish, like many, say, Auschwitz Jews, took deadly advantage of their own weakest, neither the Irish nor Jewish communities had hand or part in the conceiving and planning of the genocides from London and Berlin; respectively. Or perhaps one should say in the Irish mind, for this was a notion that appealed to many educated and discriminating men and women, and not only to the revolutionary minority.

Next

The Irish Famine was Genocide

irish potato famine genocide

During the years of the Irish Famine, Ireland produced enough food, flax and wool not only to feed and clothe its nine million people, but enough for eighteen million. Most damning of all however is that the whole discussion ignores that fact that since Elizabethan times, the Crown had had a policy of extermination. The best example of this phenomenon was fever, which exacted the greatest death toll. It took more; for profit and to exterminate the people of Ireland. The English are not racist, they hate everybody equally. This is a descriptive title, and yes there was a terrible famine. Crippling Debt Lord John Russell's government made it clear that any monetary aid coming from Britain including the work program funds was a loan.

Next

Debate Argument: The Potato was a genocide against the Irish

irish potato famine genocide

I have no issue with the british public. The Irish Government carried out a long and detailed investigation into the two bombs which exploded in Dublin. The English, indeed, call the famine a 'dispensation of Providence;' and ascribe it entirely to the blight on potatoes. She moved to Australia in 1991 and now lives in the north of Scotland. I wonder when someone will finally make a film like this about the Nakba. It was just as available to Irish government-subsidized authors and academicians.

Next

Was the Irish famine a genocide?

irish potato famine genocide

. Brits said it best… kudos to the Brits! Seed potatoes were scarce in 1847. The facts are not lost or difficult to find, the ships logs with lists of the tons of food which was exported from Eire still exist. For some commentators, the charge sheet adds up to neglect rather than genocide. The only positive thing that anyone has accomplished is that I now know better than to comment on anything having to do with Ireland. History of Ireland and the Irish Diaspora illustrated ed.

Next

Was the Irish Potato Famine really a genocide? : AskHistorians

irish potato famine genocide

There was no pseudo science of eugenics in 1847. They invade, they take over, they turn people against one another, they suck the land and its population dry, they steal from and discard the host, or at least try to. My father was Irish, born in Ireland, my mother was English, born in England and they were both very well aware of the horrors of the Famine. I have brought these topics on other forums in the past and been verbally abused for it. Many White people also wanted to kill Blacks in America. And further, constituting herself the almoner and agent of all that charity, she, England, took all the profit of it. My opinion is that this even was a genocide.

Next

officialbritishintent

irish potato famine genocide

Their excuse that they should not interfere with the economy was just a subtext to what they truly wanted. He was heir to a substantial Galway estate in 1847, which he dissipated by gambling debts on the turf in the late 1840s and early 1850s. The Famine, or An Górta Mór, the Great Hunger, took more than one million lives, between those that died of starvation and those that left Ireland for a better life in America or elsewhere in the world. As a republican I am simply not prepared to give such information. Had these recommendations been implemented, it would have done much to mitigate against the scale of the disaster which engulfed Ireland just over a decade later. I want no middle class properties and no middle class women for Hector. Laissez faire turned into Leave them to die.

Next

Was The Irish Famine Genocide?

irish potato famine genocide

I'm Cymry and we have long, long, long memories. Perhaps this brochure will encourage them to finally tell the truth; that Britain perpetrated a Holocaust in Ireland. Thanks for a thought provoking post! It is important to realize that the actions of the Victors in the above example created the on-going resentment and failure of the culture to be assimilated. Coogan highlights in a variety of ways how Trevelyan's policies consigned a generation of Irish people to death or exile. Together with the , the Great Famine in Ireland produced the greatest loss of life in 19th-century Europe. I suggest you find out what adverse really means so that you can use properly next time. He also told me about many horrific acts that were committed against the Irish, such as Bloody Sunday, and other stories about cruelty and murder.

Next

Was The Irish Famine Genocide?

irish potato famine genocide

That agreement is badly broken and needs removed. I keep thinking of what we were and are taught in a typical Israeli school where years of reading through the Tanakh are mandatory. Your argument no longer has any relevance. Colonialism and settler-colonialism are primarily a house invasion, a brutal act of control, rape, theft and thuggery. Ireland is still a country with abundant agricultural wealth.

Next